Was george wrong to kill lennie

This is where george did wrong he is worse than lennie for killing him even though they were so close and such good friends, for what reason does he have to kill him. The point of this scene was not to justify if george had the right to kill lennie or not of course it's illegal, and not right but george did what he thought was right he knew lennie very well. Best answer: lennie would of been tortured and asking george for help and why would they do this while he stands there helpless the problem in weed was he didn't kill anyone, he just touched them, the problem in their new environment that he did kill someone, the girl. Of mice and men persuasive essay by trigger october 15, 2011 in this story of mice and men by john steinbeck, i strongly believe that george was right to kill lennie we can all argue back and forth whether george killing lennie was wrong or not but the fact of the matter is—there was no escape, or time to plan the next step because.

Best answer: lennie is mentally unfit to stand trial he's mentally unfit to be tried or sentenced to prison for the crime of killing curly's wife lennie never tried to kill curly's wife and he didn't kill her on purpose lennie is so mentally incompetent - it's not likely he was aware that he could even. I largely disagree with the title of this essay and believe that george did the right by killing him, george history homework answers app stopped on was george wrong to kill lennie (ct 28, 2016, 2-3 pm. @ ali i agree with you that george shouldn't have heartlessly killed lennie but george did kill lennie trying to protect him, if george didn't kill lennie he would have gotten shot in the gut and tortured if he didn't and george was sick of running from people chasing him for stuff lennie did.

Best answer: george killed lennie, because he did not want lennie to suffer at the hands of curley curley said that he would shoot him, if he found him so george did not want lennie to suffer that way also slim had said that if for some reason they did find lennie and took him alive that it would be no. It would have been seen as george putting lennie out of his (future) misery, killing him in the most peaceful way with lennie thinking about his dreams and aspirations in comparison to how the others would have killed him. So, according to the divine command theory, george was unethical to kill lennie, because george violated to the 6th commandment, “thou shalt not kill” therefore, no matter george’s motive, according to divine command theory, killing ethically is wrong. He's going to kill him he shoots him in the back of the head, he shoots him with the luger in the most humane way possible because he had to do it because he was lennie's friend. George dreams of putting together enough money to buy a small piece of land where he and lennie can build a home he hopes that in california the two can realize their dream.

George did lennie a favor by killing him because he prevented lennie from getting hurt in the future lennie had no way of surviving without george because george was the one guiding lennie on what was right and wrong. George will regret killing lennie for the rest of his life answered by coco s #17435 on 1/11/2008 10:06 am no, i think he will miss lennie terribly, and the implication in the book is that george will end up like all the other ranch guys--lonely, directionless, spending his money on booze and women. This is when george chooses to shoot lennie at close range before the mob gets a hold of him if you ask how george was wrong in killing lennie, one could come up with two reasons.

The second option for george was to kill lennie the reason for this would be to put lennie out of his misery people made fun of him, and george knew that lennie's and his dream would never come true with lennie's mental disability in the way. George had to do it for everybody’s sake because lennie could had done the same thing again, then slim said to the suffering george “never you minda guy got to sometimes” lennie not being very bright likes to stroke live creatures and at all times he kills them. This feature is not available right now please try again later. When george had made the decision to shoot lennie, he had considered all the other options there were and had come to the conclusion that this was the only one where lennie wouldn’t have suffered, and he was correct whether he had meant to kill curley’s wife or not, lennie is still a murderer.

Was george wrong to kill lennie

was george wrong to kill lennie Was george right to kill lennie  ‘george was wrong to shoot lennie’ how far do you agreesupport your ideas with details from the novel ‘of mice and men’ is a novel written by john steinbeck that was first published in 1937 steinbeck has a very particular style of writing.

George does not want to see lennie die himself, he does not want lennie to experience a painful deathhence, he ask lennie to look in another direction and expectantly shoots him in the endit is an emotional scene in the movie and a very important ending for the novel, make sure u totally understand his reasons-as it could come up in exams. There really is no fine line in between the two they tend to overlap and so we become unsure of what is right and wrong yes, george did kill lennie but he didn't murder him the words kill and murder may seem to mean the same thing but in reality they don't george gave to lennie what any true. We will write a custom essay sample on how does steinbeck present the relationship between george and lennie in “of mice and men we will write a custom essay sample on how does steinbeck present the relationship between george and lennie in “of mice and men was george wrong to kill lennie “of mice and men”: george’s actions at. George killed lennie in of mice and men because he was looking out for the best interest of lennie curly had a group together to go and either lynch or shoot lennie to kill him for revenge.

Question: was george right to kill lennie in john steinbeck’s of mice and men example: one reason george is wrong in his decision lies in the fact that no member of just before george kills lennie, steinbeck writes, “the hand shook violently, but his face set and his hand steadied” (106). George also warns lennie to not be near curley’s wife, as he senses trouble between the two nevertheless, at the conclusion of the book, lennie accidentally kills curley’s wife after trying to calm her down (as she was screaming for help because small would not let go of her soft hair.

Lennie obviously has no concept of consequences, since he can't even remember the wrong that he did so we have to ask: it just for george to keep dragging lennie around with him or should george have taken action before lennie ended up killing someone. The decision was emotional because george did eventually lose hope for lennie, and also practical because george thought that dying would be better than the harsh treatment lennie would otherwise face. Of mice and men and lennie essay of mice and men summer reading project novel by: jhon steinbeck 9/24/13 p 6 by: zacmayle of mice and men is a story about two men, a brainy but scrawny man named george and a tall but slow thinking man named lennie, in search of work. The relationship between george and lennie in of mice and men relationship between george and lennie in of mice and men from the start to the end of the book the most important and dramatic characters are george and lennie.

was george wrong to kill lennie Was george right to kill lennie  ‘george was wrong to shoot lennie’ how far do you agreesupport your ideas with details from the novel ‘of mice and men’ is a novel written by john steinbeck that was first published in 1937 steinbeck has a very particular style of writing. was george wrong to kill lennie Was george right to kill lennie  ‘george was wrong to shoot lennie’ how far do you agreesupport your ideas with details from the novel ‘of mice and men’ is a novel written by john steinbeck that was first published in 1937 steinbeck has a very particular style of writing. was george wrong to kill lennie Was george right to kill lennie  ‘george was wrong to shoot lennie’ how far do you agreesupport your ideas with details from the novel ‘of mice and men’ is a novel written by john steinbeck that was first published in 1937 steinbeck has a very particular style of writing. was george wrong to kill lennie Was george right to kill lennie  ‘george was wrong to shoot lennie’ how far do you agreesupport your ideas with details from the novel ‘of mice and men’ is a novel written by john steinbeck that was first published in 1937 steinbeck has a very particular style of writing.
Was george wrong to kill lennie
Rated 5/5 based on 46 review

2018.